Tough Talk
Watching Brian Ferren of Applied Minds address Smithsonian 2.0.
What's he saying? Well, he says to the Smithsonian: You're becoming a dinosaur, like network TV news did back in the day, which is why no one watches it any more; or like the automotive industry, which is why they're in failure and new technologies will bypass them. He's suggesting that museums are on the verge of becoming irrelevant, because the fundamentals of the industry are not changing along with the culture.
I think we certainly agree there; the old ways don't work. Younger people, on the whole, don't care that much about museums, on the whole. He challengingly suggests that maybe museums were a fad, like CB radio, that had a historical heyday that's passing. Now, that's a pretty important question - are they a technology that no longer serves a purpose? I don't think so. But if not, then what is the purpose? Our inability to articulate one, as a profession, is at the very heart of our problems.
However, think of libraries - they are not suffering the same profound crisis of identity and meaning. They are finding that what they have to offer is not only the books - but access to information and the ability to organize information. They have identified, as Ferren says, their "core competencies." What they can do that others can't. And they still have a role.
But museums have yet to clarify their relationships with their objects, in the same way that libraries have clarified their relationship with media. Therein lies a problem - we don't know exactly what we do, besides preserve the objects.
But what's his solution? Well, he tries dialogue, saying that kids fell away from network news because they "wanted to be part of the dialogue."
But I ask: did that happen? Did making news go in two directions make younger people interested in news? Not really. The problem was that the news didn't meet its audience where its audience was - it stopped focusing on its core competency, filtering the events of the day to create a public discourse informed by the same basic information. Had the network newscasts done that, they wouldn't be totally useless today. Proof? Well, young people are interested in news - tons of it. They get their event-filtering and discourse fodder on The Daily Show and Stephen Colbert, Fox News and Rush Limbaugh. The aim of objectivity is lost, but not the filtering and not the basis for conversation. The network news died because it continued to focus on one imagined audience and let the others trickle away (I remember the night when Tom Brokaw reported on the youth of the Clinton White House staff, saying 'our children are running the White House.' Whose children was he talking about? "Ours?" I was nineteen. Was this my news?)
It's not, so much, a two-way conversation that's going to save museums, or any other medium, for that matter. Most of the time the opportunity for that conversation is not taken advantage of. Most people don't want so much a two-way conversation with a source of information as they want to share the information itself with others - friends, contacts, family - and have a conversation with them, the chosen community - not a conversation with a stranger.
I do think it will always blow boomers' minds that we can have mass communication that's not one-way, and that might be what we're seeing in the advice referencing 'dialogue.' But dialogue is too limiting a term, and I think sets up a wrong conception of how a museum staff might relate to its audience. What new technologies make possible is really not just two-way, and it's not just that you can talk back to a source -- it's that you can now communicate in ways that are multidirectional, multiplatform, and multilayered. The magic of connectivity is not that we can talk back - it's that we can talk about, with whoever we choose, to ourselves, to our friends, to our followers, to no one in particular. This content we're interested in can become part of our social lives, and part of our own process of identity-building. Sure, sometimes we get to have those wonderful moments of flatness, where we connect directly with someone who's close to the topic we're exploring, or even is the subject of what we're looking at. But for the most part, people today aren't approaching artifact-based institutions with the idea of interrogating them in some mano-a-mano fashion.
When we ask people what they want in museums, they so often say what Ferren says: that people want to see everything, not just what's on display; they want to see unprocessed objects, without the filters; etc., etc. These are fairly predictable responses from people who like museums but still feel a little unsatisfied with their experiences. And yet, when I've watched people in situations where they have access to that experience - well, it's not that effective. I remember being at the Strong Museum of Play last fall, and watching a group of already-object-headed people really gush over their open storage cases full of toys of every kind from every era...for the first room. And the second, a little. And then they skipped a few rows and found a third that was cool. And then they skipped a little faster. And then they really started to glaze over and move faster and finally drifted back to the environment that was organized much better for appreciation and attention. And I was among them, and I don't remember a damn thing I saw in those cases, only a wash of toystoystoys that is undifferentiated and unremarkable in memory, as cluttered as a flea market table and a lot less interesting because of the stultifying repetition of form.
We really don't want to see the chaos of unfamiliar objects, thousands, one after the other, with little organization. Not a whole lot of it. It's almost never a pleasant experience and not one people really enjoy for what it is. They enjoy it in ways they can only imagine - "What if this were my attic, and I could play with all this stuff?" -- but it's not, and you can't. I think empirical evidence from real museums shows that people, faced with enormous collections of things, don't take much in. It's overwhelming and not friendly to our perception of visual information. That presentation method, as we've found, can be fun as a refresher, but not as the main meal.
Hands down, when people describe great and powerful museum experiences that changed them, and created value for them, they fall into only two categories:
1. What Kiersten Latham and other scholars have called the "numinous" museum experience - a deeply moving, perhaps spiritual moment of perception of meaning in an object set forth to be viewed.
2. Guided experiences in which a passionate and knowledgeable expert shows an object or collection at its best, with depth and excitement. These are the 'behind-the-scenes' moments which people consitently rave about, jealously pursue, and which professionals enter the field specifically to experience. And that's a human experience - with all our exhibit technologies, whether they be labels or installations or pages on the internet or 3D environments, all we are doing is trying to approximate the power of that human experience as best we can without the expense of installing passionate experts in every gallery and room.
What do those experiences have in common? It's not dialogue. But it is something else Ferren promotes. It's story. Narrative. The human desire to impose a dramatic order on events and objects. Ferren suggests we should "be in the middle of the reinvention of America," and when museums, particularly history museums, reach for that, they have relevance.
Ferren makes great points about storytelling, and it is, in fact, what is happening in both types of profound museum experiences. In a numinous experience, we tell a story to ourselves, with the object as catalyzing force. The object's physical presence and details fire up a set of neurons that haven't acted in concert before, and it's powerful. The story they tell us is almost always a variation of "I understand. I didn't get it before, and now I understand more." It's what happened to Ferren at the Pantheon - though I think he gets in wrong when he says that an interaction with an object has to mean making discoveries that have never been made before, by anyone. That hardly ever happens - but understanding like you have never had before, that happens in museums every day. There is also a tremendous power in making discoveries that have been made before - in truth-testing, or touchstoning, in proving to ourselves that our grandmother's story, or Mark Twain's story, or Julius Ceasar's or Buzz Aldrin's stories might really be true - because here is the evidence, more complex and more real than we had imagined. If the story is not about understanding, it is about wonder and assimilation: "I never knew such a thing could be. I never saw that or thought about that before. A new part of my experience of the world just came into being. My mind has new models and tools; I'm changed; my identity has changed." The power of numinous experiences lies in those narratives about ourselves, I believe.
And in the guided experience, the intelligence of the guide is assisting us in giving objects their stories - stories we alone simply do not have the background to tell ourselves. What the average person can bring to an unmediated interaction with a new object, whether it's a gemstone or a bird skin or a portrait, is some amount of immediate perception and feeling. There are varying degrees of background that can help with the interpretation of a new object, though as often as not people are mistaken about what they are seeing. But a guided experience can unlock much more, by interweaving factual information, perspective, and context with what the viewer already has inside them to bring to this interaction. In a word, it's enriching, in the way a gardener enches soil - the viewer brings the soil, which contains some material but perhaps not the right balance to grow meaningful new understanding -- what happens is that the guide turns over the soil, adding compost, adding water, providing just the right fertilizer and nutrient balance to make growth happen that could not happen without the interaction with a knowledgeable authority. But it's not the dialogue itself that's doing it - a dialogue with someone uninformed and uninterested in the topic would not be enriching. So while collaboration is a good way to think about it, it matters, very much, who the collaborators are and what they bring in. It's the enrichment of the fully developed story that the guide provides, combined with the numinosity of the objects themselves when given the right attention, that creates the power of the story.
In the end, it's a human experience. If the end goal of any museum is to create changed human beings, human beings with more understanding, then the only questions we need ask ourselves to begin understanding core competencies is: how and when do objects change human beings? What does it take for an object to create a change in a human being? And we know much of that - it takes a story, a human intelligence telling tales, whether that happens inside a viewer or in a group of two or more people telling a tale together. Can objects do that alone? Very rarely, and dimensions are lost. So what must we add in order to leverage the power of the object? What we add are human elements. Technologies are just ways for us to use our human capacities to better effect. Losing focus on the fact that museums are places where objects and their stories change human beings means getting bogged down in questions about nuts and bolts. Our core competency is helping people gain understanding from stuff, and we do it by organizing topic-focused presentations of objects, as carefully crafted as a public lecture. And we can be good at it if we understand what we're setting out to do, and then find the appropriate tools.

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home