You Mean You Think the Public Might Actually Know Something?
Yesterday, I took our summer interns on a mini-field trip to a local historical society -- we'll call it Olde GeBip Towne Historical Society. This place has several very interesting properties, all pretty well exhibited, if a bit eccentric, as local historical societies sometimes tend to be. The MegaMuseums don't always take them very seriously.
Olde GeBip is in the process of re-doing their labels in a 1653 building which once housed the town's prison cells and storerooms. This is high season, and they didn't want to cut off visitor access while they redid the labels. So they decided, in a sudden and admirable stroke of sharp thinking, to include the visitor.
The labels are mounted on a rail-fence type barrier, on angled boards. The Olde GeBip staff printed out the proposed label text on plain paper, added some cut-and-paste images to stand in for the eventual graphics, and mounted everything on long strips of brown kraft paper. (Thanks, Martha Stewart -- I used to think that it was just called "brown paper," but you set me straight). It looks like what it is, a homebuilt mock-up -- very Sixth-Grade Science Fair. Humble.
They taped the brown paper on top of the existing labels, in such a way that you can read the proposed text, but you can also lift the paper to see the text it is replacing. Then -- and here's the genius part -- as visitors enter the room, the interpreter explains that they're redeveloping the labels, hands the visitors a pen and a stack of Post-It notes, and invites people to have at it. They're doing this for a week.
The proposed labels were already good. But guess what? Visitors --yes, the great unwashed American tourist public that is so often a target for museumite contempt -- had a lot of useful things to say. They caught and corrected typos, suggested clearer wordings, spotted not one but two apocryphal stories about word derivations (sending the curators scurrying for sources), made comments about font choices that are easier for new readers to understand, asked questions about the exhibit that the label had ignored, and even pointed out that the spindle on the spinning wheel was pointing the wrong way. And, along the way, they were treated as smart people whose contributions to the museum would be useful and valued. All those who think "interactive" means mouse-clicking, button-pushing electronic excitement should observe a process like this. Electronic junkies: witness the fun, the level of engagement, the thought, the group interaction, and the careful attention that every visitor brought to this exhibit. Still think you need the animatronics?
And, as a result, their labels will be a lot better. I could only think regretfully of the many installations I've seen going up without enough eyes having reviewed them. Sadly, the standard process is for a small team of rather enmeshed people to work on the labels, unveiling them to the rest of the museum staff only at a very late stage of development -- and usually at the eleventh hour, when suggestions and emendations are most unwelcome. Normally a broad range of staff comments aren't even sought, let alone visitor comments. Many's the time I have worked in a newly installed exhibit, and spent the day cringingly waiting for visitors to point out all the simple typos and grammatical errors and misplaced captions and compiling a list for after-market fixes. That's how you get those cute labels with the extra piece of vinyl screen patched over a mispelled word. Very professional. And at that stage, you can only hope for simple corrections. You can't really rephrase something for clarity, or re-arrange label elements to bring in more visual interest, or suggest the addition of a graphic.
So, well done, Olde Gebip Towne Historical Society. You may be small and eccentric, but you're doing something very right. You're reminding us that visitors have knowledge and insight, too. After all, they're people who are spending their own precious recreational time and disposable income to come look at our dusty old stuff -- it's safe to say they probably have some curiosity, some knowledge of the topic, and an honest desire to build on what they know. The MegaMuseums would do well to follow your example.

3 Comments:
Go GeBip! What a great story! Are they hiring? Do they need a website?!
Wow. When I read the first half of your post I was thinking, "oh dear god, don't tell me they included Joe Blow's comments on their labels..." And then you schooled me with the second half of your post. You are right; if someone cares enough to come to the museum, they no doubt have something of value to add that The Management might not have considered.
I love your comment about different types of interactivity -- how true. (And really, how much more fun for the user to interact in a tangible way? Digital interaction can be very cool, but there's something about physicality that bits and bytes will never be able to replicate.)
Post a Comment
<< Home