I Went There : The Lower East Side Tenement Museum
On one of the coldest days of the year, the corner of Orchard & Broome streets resembles a frozen-over Hell. Perfect weather for a visit to a historic site well equipped to illustrate the idea of hardship. Situated in the heart of New York City's Lower East Side, a neighborhood that served as a first American home to generations of struggling immigrants, the Lower East Side Tenement Museum is housed in a couple of unprepossessing buildings blending subtly with the Sesame-style streetscape. It makes the most of its sense of place, on a block that remains busy and commercial. Garment dealers in black vests and yarmulkes, Chinese tailors, Middle Eastern table vendors, and venerable fine-foods purveyors step right out onto the street to accost visitors with good ol' American hucksterism, delivering the hard sell on bargain-priced clothing,linens, pickles and pashminas. It's not a great leap to imagine this city block circa 1900 -- add a few horse-drawn produce wagons, subtract a few well-heeled museumgoers in furs and North Face.
Orientation: We arrived from the subway with excellent directions from the museum's web site. With the wind chill below zero and a bright cold sun barely peeking over the tops of these 4-and 5-story buildings, the visitors' center was a welcome refuge. The center doubles as a gift shop -- OK, so it's mostly a gift shop. Tour tickets are sold at the counter, and orientation material consists of a History Channel video looping in a side room. We had pre-purchased our tix online; recommended and a good thing, since the museum was busy-busy. On this morning, just two days after Christmas, the shop gave shelter to a crush of humanity reminiscent of Ellis Island. The store's wares, mostly an excellent selection of books on immigration and New York history, were pawed over and held aloft for inspection like a cartful of melons. The feel of a crowded neighborhood marketplace was lovingly recreated here, complete with some good-natured New York shoving and elbowing.
Tours start with a shouted cattle-call from a museum educator. There were three tour titles offered the day of this visit; we chose 'Getting By' for its hardship and social-welfare themes, and also because it promised visits to two different apartments within the tenement. We followed our educator/guide back out into the Arctic street. He led us up a stoop and into a dim storefront room, furnished with early 20th-century enamel kitchen tables. After settling in, we were asked to share names, hometowns, and countries of ancestry. With this technique, the tour became personal immediately and began with visitor experience as a starting point. Amongst just the three family groups on the tour, we represented Italian, Danish, Irish, French, and Northern European backgrounds.
Content: Our guide, in an informed but casual manner, gave a brief introduction to immigration and the concept of 'tenement,' asking the group what we thought it meant. A nice interpretive trick: 'tenement' simply means a dwelling housing three or more unrelated families. About half the group, the apartment dwellers, had to admit that they currently live in a tenement. The words 'apartment house', 'condominium,' and the like were created to soothe middle-class sensibilities, he added.
Up we got and trooped upstairs. In the narrow hallway, the guide stopped to extinguish the electric lights, allowing us to see how much daylight was available - not much. After the snow-bright street, the interior hall was cavelike and creepy. A few streaks of light from the transom were sufficient to stumble upstairs by during the day; at night, you'd want a candle or lamp.
The tour presented two apartments for comparison, one depicting the 1870s, the other the 1930s. The families interpreted had been very well researched through archaeology, records searches, and oral history. Our guide's storytelling was excellent, building interest and sympathy with real individuals through gentle humor and plenty of vivid, concrete detail. The rivetingly detailed interiors were nicely complemented by laminated photocopies of a few photos and primary source materials. When possible the stories were extended into the present day, and photos and anecdotes of modern-day descendants and their families brought a realness to the story that is so often lacking in historic homes. We were enabled to imagine how the story has 'turned out' so far, which certainly informs our understandings of the sacrifices immigrants made and the struggle to get a foothold in the New World.
Questioning strategies were used to great effect; the guide rarely told us anything without asking for reflections or observations first. Most visitors were more eager to offer answers than they usually are at other historic sites. Apparently, the tenement atmosphere is seen by visitors as welcoming and familiar. At last they were standing in an environment they understood, that gybed with family recollections and, in some cases, brought back first-person memories. This personal connection to American family stories is a great success for this museum; the reactions of tourgoers were not what you'd find on a tour of a Georgian country home or Victorian mansion. An oral history recording lent a nice touch in the Baldizzi family apartment: a remembrance of kitchen activities by the family's daughter called attention to small details like the box of Linit starch over the sink, the soup bowls on the table and pots on the stove, and the radio, tuned to Italian music from home.
Wrap-Up: The tour ended in an empty, drafty back room where the sensation of winter in a building lacking central heat was quite realistic. Here the guide asked us to generalize about universality in the immigrant experience, and note the differences between 1870s and 1930s immigration. The tricky part came when we talked about how the challenges of immigration in the past compare with the present day. Social welfare and reform legislation made the 1930s immigrant experience easier, healthier, and somewhat less stressful than it had been in previous generations, as the tour was meant to illustrate. But when it came to modern immigration issues, a disconnect was apparent; romantic ideas about heroic struggle and eventual success were presented as accepted platitudes by our group, despite the guide's mention of the gradual dismantling of the social safety net and the intrusions of the Patriot Act. The idea, however inaccurate, of the self-sufficient, bootstrap American is powerful and persistent. The third- and fourth- generation Americans recount a family legend emphasizing hard work and faith leading to eventual reward, while discounting the help provided by religious organizations, government food and housing subsidies, and laws regulating health and housing conditions. Too, we underplay the sacrifice immigrants made in taking up work for which they were vastly overqualified (but forced by discrimination to accept); the long nights of doubt, questionning whether leaving the home country was indeed worthwhile; and the separation from family and friends that hurts every minute. The descendants of early 20th century immigrant families are likely to believe that it is now easier than ever for a disadvantaged family from another country to quickly make good on America's promise; a belief not so well borne out by economic realities.
I'd love to chat with Tenement Museum staff about these conversations; I'm sure sometimes they are emotional, personal, heated, and political. Our guide did a remarkable job of presenting ideas in a neutral manner and describing the range of scholarly and public opinion without strongly stating a position -- though he himself is the son of immigrants, and could no doubt make some insightful personal observations in another setting.
Out the back fire escape we went, clattering downstairs like a gang of kids from A Tree Grows in Brooklyn. To escape the cold we returned again to the gift shop, where another cat-herd was assembling another tour.
The Underside: The museum is managing in fine immigrant spirit, but I would like to see a big permanent exhibit as part of the visitors' center. According to the guide, there were more apartments in the building, and I wonder if there's not an unrestored space that could function as an exhibit on the evolution of the neighborhood, site archaeology, immigration in New York, and the like. After one of these tours, you're wanting a way to extend the experience and meditate on it a bit; and there's no satisfactory place to do that as yet. (I'm sure it's on the wish list). Also, the introductory room seemed to have a pile of displaced office equipment at the back of it. I know we never have enough storage, but...we felt a little bit like we were sitting in the supply closet.
The Up Side: Nieghborhood setting; well-informed, qualified guide; good storytelling; frequent questioning; related content to previous visitor knowledge; comfortable pace; sophisticated issues and mention of less-glamorous topics like prostitution, crime, and outhouses; good book selection in store; evocative interiors; and an incredibly inspiring winner of a theme which so many Americans can relate to. Finally, sitting around kitchen tables during the introduction was a nice touch - what could put Americans more at ease with one another than sitting around the kitchen table?

2 Comments:
Excellent write-up. My father grew up on the lower East Side of NYC and I recently went there to check out his former digs. While walking around his old neighborhood, I found the Orchard Street museum and helped myself on a tour. I found the entire thing fascinating, informative... just great fun, even the somewhat depressing parts. Really enjoyed your piece!
Why thank you! My first comment, and I'm amazed at how quickly the site was discovered...I only started it yesterday. Wonders! Hope you'll return and tell others. It's still under construction (as if you couldn't tell) but bear with me. Thanks.
Post a Comment
<< Home